Knicks vs Pacers: Basketball’s Timeless Rivalry

Some basketball rivalries are short-lived, flaring up for a season or two before fading away. Others, like the New York Knicks and the Indiana Pacers, refuse to die. This matchup has lasted nearly five decades, spanning eras, generations, and styles of play — yet it still carries the same heat it did in the 1990s.

At its core, this rivalry is about more than wins and losses. It’s about personalities, culture clashes, and moments so dramatic they’ve been replayed for decades. From Reggie Miller’s unforgettable “choke” gesture at Spike Lee to Tyrese Haliburton taunting New York in 2025, Knicks vs Pacers has become a living piece of NBA theatre.

A Timeline of Rivalry

The easiest way to understand the depth of Knicks vs Pacers is to walk through the key years. Each clash added new layers of drama, heartbreak, or triumph.

The Rivalry’s DNA

So, what makes this feud so magnetic? Why do fans still talk about Knicks vs Pacers like it’s more than just basketball?

1. Born in the Playoffs

This isn’t a typical rivalry born from location, like Knicks vs Nets or Lakers vs Clippers. Knicks vs Pacers grew in the postseason, where every possession mattered. Almost every classic meeting had championship implications, adding intensity and urgency.

2. Reggie Miller, New York’s Villain

Reggie Miller wasn’t just a great shooter; he was a showman. He thrived under pressure, and he loved silencing Madison Square Garden. Whether it was scoring 25 points in a fourth quarter or drilling threes while jawing at Spike Lee, Miller made New York his personal stage.

3. Spike Lee, the Super fan

Speaking of Spike, few rivalries have featured a fan as central to the drama. His trash talk and sideline energy made Miller’s antics even more iconic. Their “battle” became symbolic of the larger war between Indiana and New York.

4. Cultural Clash

This is Broadway vs the Midwest. Bright lights, big-city swagger, and MSG energy clashing with Indiana’s small-market grit and heartland pride. It’s not just basketball; it’s identity.

5. Generations of Stars

The rivalry has seamlessly passed from one era to another. Patrick Ewing vs Reggie Miller gave way to Larry Johnson vs Jalen Rose, then Carmelo Anthony vs Paul George, and now Jalen Brunson vs Tyrese Haliburton. The faces change, but the fire never does.

Iconic Moments That Live Forever

• The “Choke” Game (1994) – Miller lights up MSG for 25 in the fourth quarter, mocking Spike Lee with his hands around his throat. The picture is still one of the most famous in NBA history.

• 8 Points in 9 Seconds (1995) – In one of the most stunning finishes ever, Miller scores eight points in the final nine seconds of Game 1, shocking Knicks fans and etching himself into rivalry folklore.

• Larry Johnson’s Four-Point Play (1999) – Down late, Johnson drills a three while getting fouled. He hits the free throw, and MSG erupts in one of the loudest roars ever recorded in the Garden.

• The Collapse of 2025 – In Game 1 of the Eastern Conference Finals, the Knicks blew a 17-point lead, handing Indiana a confidence-shattering win. For fans, it was déjà vu — another gut punch in a rivalry built on heartbreak.

The Modern Chapter

After years of quiet, Knicks vs Pacers roared back in 2024. The Pacers, led by Tyrese Haliburton, stunned the Knicks in a gruelling seven-game series. Then in 2025, the Pacers did it again, this time in the Conference Finals.

Game 1 of that series was a microcosm of the rivalry itself: drama, heartbreak, and history repeating itself. The Knicks looked ready to dominate, then collapsed under the bright lights. The Pacers smelled blood, and once again, Indiana walked away celebrating.

What’s Ahead

This rivalry isn’t slowing down. Both teams are young, talented, and hungry. Jalen Brunson has become the heart of the Knicks, while Haliburton is Indiana’s floor general and trash-talking spark.

Fans don’t have to wait long:

• December 18, 2025 – The Knicks and Pacers meet again in the regular season. It’s not the playoffs, but the atmosphere will feel like one.

And if destiny brings them together in the postseason again? Expect another chapter worthy of highlight reels.

Why It Still Matters

1. It’s Emotional – The highs and lows of this rivalry feel personal for both fan bases.

2. It’s Historic – Few matchups can boast this many iconic playoff series.

3. It’s Alive – The names change, but the story continues. Knicks vs Pacers remains must-watch basketball.

Final Word

The Knicks vs Pacers rivalry is everything that makes sports beautiful. It’s theater, it’s heartbreak, it’s celebration. It has villains and heroes, iconic moments, and an energy that transcends the court.

For nearly 50 years, these two teams have battled not just for wins, but for pride, respect, and bragging rights. And the best part? The rivalry is still being written.

Whenever the Knicks and Pacers face off — whether in Madison Square Garden or Gainbridge Fieldhouse — fans know something special might happen. This isn’t just basketball. This is history in motion.

READ MORE : The Battle of the White Balls Begins: South Africa vs. England